Tag Archives: Dr. Downing

Childbirth Court Case — Saunders Vs Dr Downing

Standard

32675385_10155764492371886_638919317773090816_n.jpg

January 1900 Carleton Place Herald–
Found by Josh Greer- and property of Lisa Occomore and Brad Occomore of Valley Granite and Tile

Without calling upon Mr. G. F. Henderson, K.C., counsel for the defence, to produce argument, Mr, Justice Wright sitting in the Ontario Supreme Court at Ottawa on
Wednesday dismissed without costs the action brought by Mr. M. A. Saunders, who was  a resident of Carleton Place, against Dr. A. Downing, physician, of the same town, for damages -amounting to ‘$10,000, for the death of his wife on December 28th, 1923, which he alleged was due to malpractice on the part of the physician.

Mr. Saunders, through a number of witnesses, medical and lay, sought to prove that Dr. Downing who as the family physician, had been called upon to attend Mrs. Saunders, upon her confinement, had not properly attended upon her with the result that she had died the same day as the birth of her child from an excessive hemorrhage. Downing was also accused that has conduct had been unprofessional in that he had used offensive language towards the sick woman and members of the family assembled at her bedside. Hard to believe, but in those days words came out easy with no thoughts in the heat of the moment.

 

32675385_10155764492371886_638919317773090816_n.jpg

January 1900 Carleton Place Herald–
Found by Josh Greer- and property of Lisa Occomore and Brad Occomore of Valley Granite and Tile

Mr. G. F. Henderson, K. C., for the defence submitted medical testimony from Dr. Campbell Laidlaw and Dr. Walter whose opinions based upon general medical practice, went to show that she had been subjected to what is ‘known as pulmonary embolism’, which had caused practical asphyxiation, rather than excessive hemorrhage.

Dr. Campbell Laidlaw explained to the court that pulmonary embolism was a rare
occurrence, but was met with in childbirth cases, and that it meant the forcing of a clot of blood through the arteries to the right chamber of the heart where it lodges, causing
suffocation. There is today, no known preventive or cure in medical science for this disease, which almost in every case results in death, it was asserted.

May 23 1924

blk2.jpg

Dr Johnson House

Address: Bridge Street, Carleton Place, Ontario

Originally owned by Robert Bell, the property first held a white frame home.
The present house was built in 1902 by Dr. M.A. MacFarlane, who fashioned the red brick home after a house in Scotland.
After Dr. MacFarlane’s death, the house was rented to Doctor’s Downing and Ferrill.
In 1924 Dr. Allen Johnson bought the home, and with his wife Annie established a medical practice  that was to last 45 year
October 17 1942

The Sad Tale of Unwed Mothers of Days Gone By — Perth through the Ages Tour

The Trial of Ann Glascott

Women in Peril 1868 — Mathilda Routh

The Very Sad Tale of Hessie Churchill

To Be Manic Depressive in a Rural Town — Kingston Insane Asylum

 

Dr. Johnson Downing and Ferril I Presume? Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 12 a

Standard
Dr. Johnson Downing and Ferril I Presume? Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 12 a

I found this online written in 2012 and it was printed in the Kemptville Advance from InsideOttawa.com.

I don’t know who it was written by as there was no name, but I thought I would document it here so we would not lose sight of it. I think it is Mary Cook by the style of writing and the mention of the farm. In fact if it was Vegas odds I would bet. I found a few clippings of Dr. Downing, so it seemed like a good addition.

Mary Cook's Memories

Mary Cook Books

 

The large brick house across the river was usually occupied by a doctor. Dr. MacFarlane occupied it before Dr. Chas. W. Ferrill who was a G.P. at that time and moved his practice to Cobden for a time. Dr. J.A. Johnson and his wife Ann Thompson lived there for a good number of years.

 

blk2.jpg

Photo- Linda Seccaspina

It was an imposing house to a young girl fresh off the farm. It sat majestically at the North end of the bridge on the Mississippi River in Carleton Place, and I thought surely someone with royal blood running through their veins must live in such a mansion. It was called “The Doctor’s House” and I learned that a Dr. Allen Johnson ran his family practice from this large brick home. I could see it from our much more humble home across the bridge, and felt then I would probably never get to see inside it.

However, something happened one wintery day that sent me scurrying across that bridge and into the doctor’s crowded waiting room. I inadvertently severed the leg of my beloved canary when cleaning its cage, and wrapping it in a face cloth and putting it in a small sewing basket, I tore across the bridge and into the red brick mansion, wailing my heart out. Dr. Johnson immediately took me and my basket into his office and performed a “surgery”. He attached two toothpicks around the little stub, wrapped them in tape, and sent me on my way. There was no charge and the little bird lived with his toothpick “prosthesis” for years! At last, I was inside the mansion across the bridge!

 

alien

Photo- Linda Seccaspina

Alone, the Doctor’s House deserves a place in our history books. Add Dr. and Mrs. Allen Johnson into the mix, visiting dignitaries, and a few ghosts, and we now have a story of dedication, service and legends, about which most people of the present generation know little.

It wasn’t always brick. First, it was white frame, built by the son of the Reverend Bell, the first minister in Perth.

It is believed the present house was fashioned off a castle-like mansion seen by Dr. M. A. MacFarlane who studied in Scotland, and who purchased the property, and built the home in 1902, which is still standing today, in spite of a devastating fire in 1945. This is where Dr. MacFarlane conducted his practice and raised his family. When Dr. MacFarlane died, it remained “The Doctor’s House” when Drs. Downing and Ferrill took it over.

In 1924, a young doctor, well known in the Ottawa Valley, Dr. Allen Johnson, bought the home and with his wife Annie, established a medical practice that was to continue for the next 45 years.

asar

Photo- Linda Seccaspina

 

Doctor Johnson’s contribution to Carleton Place, goes much beyond his medical practice. He was the county medical officer for many years. He was elected to council in 1929, and served as Reeve of Lanark County, and the town’s mayor.

Allen Johnson was an avid Conservative, and counted amongst his friends, members of Parliament both federal and provincial. He served the party both locally and at the county level and during every election, determined to have his member re-elected, Dr. Johnson took to the roads, rapped on doors, and generally let it be known who he was supporting.

It was to the Doctor’s House that dignitaries of every stripe were welcomed, but it was well known that Dr. Johnson’s leanings towards the Conservative party saw Tory members and Premiers more frequent visitors than representatives of other parties! Mrs. Johnson, a devoted wife, opened the Doctor’s House to dignitaries and ordinary folks alike, as her husband “collected” people much like one would collect coins or stamps. Their status or station in life meant nothing to either of the Johnsons. Pauline McGibbon, Lieutenant Governor for the Province of Ontario, on a visit to Carleton Place, rested in the turret bedroom, and on orders from her office, was served a “wee nip” of her favourite embodiment.

“The Doctor’s House” was also home to many who needed a helping hand to get back on their feet. Everyone was welcome.

Vera Hawkins, now a resident at Carleton Place Manor, worked with Dr. Johnson for many years.

“Those were the days when there were no appointments…first come, first served. We had an X-Ray machine, the only one in town, and before the hospital was built, it was often used by other doctors. It took up most of a whole room, and I had to go way down in the cellar to develop the x-rays. It was pretty primitive.

“The only room that was really private was what we called the Geranium Room and it was upstairs, and we took patients up these steep and narrow steps to be examined. In the office area, the rooms opened up on each other, so everyone had to climb these narrow steps when Dr. Johnson had to do an examination.

“But he was kindness itself, and so was Mrs. Johnson, and they were both loved by everyone. And the house was amazing. I have very fond memories of my years with Dr. Johnson,” Vera told me.

83565368_2854526561270886_5528958898184126464_n

It’s Photo Friday! This crazy scene was photographed in the attic of Dr. McFarland’s home and office at 205 Bridge Street. Taken by Horace Brown in 1914, it is described by his good friend David Douglas Findlay, who wrote on the back
“this is a flashlight of me supposed to be in the DT’s (death throws?) taken in Dr. McFarland’s attic.The two ghosts are Ryan (?) McFarlane and Harry Menzies. I am supposed to be praying to them not to take me this time. That is a real human skull on the table but needless to say there is no booze in the bottle in my pocket.”

 

blk3

Photo- Linda Seccaspina

 

Dr. Johnson died suddenly at home in November 1967. He was waked at “The Doctor’s House”, and waiting in line to pay their respects were hundreds of people: simple folk, patients, and dignitaries. The line stretched from the steps leading down into the front entrance to the great house, across the bridge, and around the corner of the second block of the main street. Heading the lineup were the Honourable John Deifenbaker and his wife Olive.

After Mrs. Johnson’s death some years later, The Doctor’s House, took on a new life. It became a home and a commercial business. Where once patients lay on a black leather couch waiting to be seen, there were now weaving looms and massive arrays of coloured wools. Mississippi Black Sheep Gallery was opened by Susan and Gordon Scale, and flourished for many years.

The Scales weren’t there long when they found they weren’t alone! It all started one day when Susan was serving tea to a friend, and even though they were alone in the house, the visitor saw a man stealthily walking through the dining room. That was the first of many “sightings” and unusual happenings.

The Scales owned a black Lab and Terrier mix. One night the dog was seen tossing a ball and having it retrieved to be tossed again. There was no one there! Just the dog and an unseen being playing with their dog!

“We weren’t alarmed. But we knew without question, that we were not alone in the house,” Susan told me.

One day she actually saw an unfamiliar man walking down the driveway. “I was gardening, and I very briefly saw a short stocky man, wearing a very long reefer-type coat, like they wore in days of yore, walking in our lane.”

It wasn’t a long sighting, but long enough to confirm to Susan that a spirit had never given up “The Doctor’s House”. Was it Dr. MacFarlane? It certainly wasn’t the spirit of Dr. Johnson, who was over six feet tall! This man was very short. The Carleton Place and Beckwith Heritage Museum is searching for a picture of Dr. MacFarlane to see if a match can be found.

 

jon1

Photo by Linda Seccaspina and from the Carleton Place Canadian files of the Carleton Place and Beckwith Heritage Museum

 

Now, The Doctor’s House has taken on yet another life. It was recently bought by Duncan McNaughton, who, when looking for office space to expand his Project Management Business located in Ottawa, could see the stately home as a perfect fit to enlarge his operations and make available individual offices to lease.

While retaining the integrity of the stately old home, much has been redone and made ready. Some walls have been taken down, and updates to services put in place.

And what about the spirit of someone who refuses to entirely give up residency? Well, according to Duncan McNaughton, one of his associates, unaware of the Scales experiences, says she hears someone walking upstairs. She can never find anyone, but the sounds continue.

What a life this stately old home has had! It has seen the sick being healed, and comfort given to the dying. It has housed notables and ordinary people.

 

jon

Photo by Linda Seccaspina and from the Carleton Place Canadian files of the Carleton Place and Beckwith Heritage Museum

It has been devastated by fire, and restored to its original grandeur. And what of its future now? Will it continue to be a place of note? Duncan McNaughton is sure it will. He fully appreciates the integrity of the stately old house and Tiree’s Project Management Business has found the perfect location to expand. And whoever moves in, claiming a portion of this grand old home, should be prepared to share their space. There will be nothing to fear, though. Susan Scale says these are friendly spirits.

Are they really part of The Doctor’s House? Are they someone’s soul of times gone by, who wants to hang on to what once was? Perhaps they just want to make sure that the integrity of The Doctor’s House remains what it was meant to be when it was built 110 years ago!

 

Marg Whyte 2001– The large brick house across the river was ususally occupied by a doctor. Dr. MacFarlane occupied it before Dr. Chas. W. Ferrill who was a G.P. at that time and moved his practice to Cobden for a time. Dr. J.A. Johnson and his wife Ann Thompson lived there for a good number of years.

historicalnotes

Clipped from The Ottawa Journal,  13 Sep 1898, Tue,  Page 6

Clipped from The Ottawa Journal,  12 Jul 1937, Mon,  Page 2

 

img.jpg

Clipped from The Ottawa Journal,  27 Oct 1945, Sat,  Page 4

Ray Paquette- Dr. Running was my childhood GP until he decided to re-enlist in the RCAF. I was a friend of his eldest son, Gary, a graduate of RMC who followed his father into the RCAF before retiring and joining the Department of Transport. He currently lives on the West
Dr. Running maintained an office at the north east corner of Beckwith and Albert Streets. I remember the Saturday in the summer that Dr Running passed away following a massive heart attack while shopping in Carleton Place. At the time he was at his summer cottage on the Mississippi Lake.

Stephen Giles —The Running family cottage still stands down on the point at Beck (McNaughton) Shore.

Marilyn White- Gary took Ken Fournier to his dad at lunch time to have his head stitched. He fell in Miss MCrostie’s class. He was our family Dr. and he was one of a kind. Went to school with his son Ron.

Peter Iveson– We lived in Dr.Running’s house corner of Albert and Beckwith 1956 to 1960,where he was posted to Europe.

 

canada-150-for-website_m_300x187.jpg

Come and visit the Lanark County Genealogical Society Facebook page– what’s there? Cool old photos–and lots of things interesting to read. Also check out The Tales of Carleton Place.

Information where you can buy all Linda Seccaspina’s books-You can also read Linda in The Townships Sun andScreamin’ Mamas (US

The 1945 Fire at Dr. Johnson’s Home in Carleton Place

Ghostly Images at Doctor Johnson’s House?

Carleton Place Business–Lloyd Hughes List

Comments Comments Comments–Documenting History

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 1– Canadian Tire to The Moose

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 2- Milano Pizza to Milady Dress Shop

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 3- St. Andrew’s to Central School

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 4- Leslie’s China Shop to Rubino’s/Giant Tiger

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 5-The Little White House to the Roxy

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 6-The Eating Place to the Post Office

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 7 –Scotia Bank to the New York Cafe

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 8–Olympia Restaurant to McNeely’s–

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 9–Flint’s to the Blue Spot

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 11

Carleton Place Then and Now–Bridge Street Series– Volume 12